The launch of Owen Smith’s campaign for the Labour
leadership has left impartial observers rather bemused.
Surely, if the mainstream in the Labour Party wants to
defeat Jeremy Corbyn, they should be rallying around a single candidate?
Splitting the anti-Jez vote between Smith and Angela Eagle seems utterly
self-destructive.
Within a short time, however, it has become apparent that
Smith intends to replace Eagle as the
candidate.
The argument advanced by his supporters is that he is better
placed to beat Corbyn because he is seen as more left-wing by party members. He
will therefore ‘peel away’ people who despair of Corbyn’s incompetence, but
can’t embrace Angela Eagle’s political world view.
While this may be plausible at one level, we have to be
realistic that the chances of either of these candidates beating Corbyn are
fairly minimal right now. This is because the Corbynistas are well entrenched
and the maths simply doesn’t look that good.
But let’s, for argument’s sake, imagine that Smith could win and Eagle
couldn’t. What would his victory
actually represent?
We could see it as the replacement of an incompetent man
with someone who seems fairly competent.
But that’s only a fraction of what this trench warfare is
actually about.
Corbyn’s personal failings are legion, but it’s his ideology
– his ‘pickled dogma’, if I can borrow Neil Kinnock’s famous phrase of the
1980s’ – that we actually need to confront.
I feel that Eagle represents a far greater ideological
threat to Corbyn than a man who was clearly reluctant to leave the shadow
cabinet in the first place and has spent recent days locked in meetings trying
to find a ‘compromise’.
There is no compromise with the climate that led to a brick
being thrown through Angela Eagle’s window and threats of violence becoming the
norm.
There is no compromise with John McDonnell’s expletive-laden
ranting and commitment to extra-parliamentary socialism.
There is no compromise with the return of the very worst of
the 1980s.
Things have now gone too far.
Corbyn needs to be faced down by someone who actually wants
to reclaim the Labour Party and wave good bye to the destructive forces that have
wrecked it in under a year. Not someone
looking naively for hopeless deals.
This is now make or break.
So your obviously looking for the party to become the Tory light party again.
ReplyDeleteThe likes of Angela Eagle in the party are what drove me away from Labour originally.
I'm no troskyite I'm just a hard working bloke who despaired at the inequality in the country bought in by the Tories but unchallenged by Labour and sometimes supported by them.
Was this the Labour party you signed up for and want, because the values of the centre right of the party in my view are not the values of the Labour party I knew.
Corbyn has bought principles and a dignity to the party that has been lacking since Blair got in bed with the Bankers,Bush and Murdoch.
I would rather have a party that fought for the people and lost an election (and let's not kid ourselves, Eagle isn't going to win us one)than one that cowtowed to Tory dogma to win an election.
If the Labour party does sadly split the fault will lay squarely and fairly with the PLP and its denial of what got Corbyn elected in the first place.